Asian Conversations - an online magazine to explore Asia's future

Narendra Modi quells
fears of saffron takeover

With a renewed regional focus and an inclusive message, the new Indian PM has signalled intent as Modi 2.0. Why he should be held to this "higher" standard.

New Delhi, June 2014, TheWorldPost

BJP leader Narendra Modi, (centre), performs Hindu rituals on the banks of the river Ganges

BJP leader Narendra Modi, (centre), performs Hindu rituals on the banks of the river Ganges, Varanasi, after his landslide victory - Photo: Kevin Frayer, Getty Images

WHEN Narendra Modi swept to a dramatic victory in India's general elections, becoming the first prime minister in three decades to command an absolute majority in the lower house of India's fractious Parliament, many in India worried about what his victory would portend. To political opponents and members of India's liberal intelligentsia, Modi was a divisive, sectarian, authoritarian figure who had presided over the massacre of some 1,200 innocents, mainly Muslim, as chief minister of the state of Gujarat in 2002. The thought of such a figure leading a diverse and multi-religious polity that had long been built on the "Nehruvian consensus" developed by the Congress Party, was anathema to many.

In the event, Modi overcame this negative perception, re-branding himself as an apostle of development and pointing to his successful record in Gujarat, a state of high growth rates that under his leadership has been a magnet for investors. His brilliantly-organized, lavishly-funded election campaign saw "Hindutva", the ideology of Hindu chauvinism with which he and his Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) have long been identified, relegated to the back burner, while Modi promised voters he would remake India in the model of prosperous Gujarat. The electorate rewarded the BJP - which had never previously won more than 186 seats in India's 543-member Lower House - with 282 seats, as the National Democratic Alliance led by the BJP claimed 333. The ruling Congress Party, of which I am a member, was relegated to its worst showing in history, winning a mere 44 seats.

Shashi Tharoor

Shashi Tharoor

To almost everyone's surprise, Modi and the BJP have eschewed the hubris and triumphalism they might have been assumed to have earned with their sweeping victory... Modi has been conciliatory and inclusive in his pronouncements and actions

To almost everyone's surprise, however, Modi and the BJP have eschewed the hubris and triumphalism they might have been assumed to have earned with their sweeping victory. In the couple of weeks since his election, Modi has been conciliatory and inclusive in both his pronouncements and his actions. I was a beneficiary of this unexpected generosity on the very day of his victory, when I received a startling tweet of congratulations from him on my own victory in my constituency. "Let us work together to move India forward," he declared in his message to me.

This tweet to a prominent adversary, with whom he had crossed swords in the past, was one of many signals to the nation that he was putting old enmities behind him. "I will be prime minister of all Indians, including those who did not vote for me," he announced in one of his first speeches. Cynics might point out that this was only prudent, since his party won its resounding majority with just 31 percent of the national vote, benefitting from the Westminster-style "first-past-the-post" system in constituencies with multiple contesting parties. But coming as it did from a man with a reputation of brooking no dissent and riding roughshod over opposition during his twelve years at the helm in Gujarat, it was a welcome surprise.

In a series of speeches, Prime Minister Modi has gone out of his way to avoid confrontational language, to omit issues and imagery that India's religious minorities would find offensive, and to extend a hand of friendship to his critics. After having attacked the large number of government projects and schemes named for members of the Congress Party's Nehru-Gandhi dynasty during the election, he stopped his ministers from renaming these programmes, saying it was more important to get them to work more effectively. His early Cabinet appointments rewarded the party's brighter and younger professionals, omitting many of the Hindu nationalist veterans and rabid ideologues who epitomised many Indians' anxieties about the BJP.

In a striking departure from precedent, Modi also quelled concerns in India's neighbourhood about his rise by inviting the heads of government of India's seven South Asian neighbours, as well as that of Mauritius (the Indian Ocean republic whose population is 63 percent Indian), to his swearing-in. India's prime ministers have never enjoyed lavish inaugurations like American presidents, traditionally assuming office after sparsely-attended and low-key oath-takings behind closed doors. Modi converted this routine into a grand, opulent 4,000-guest ceremony on the forecourt of Rashtrapati Bhavan, the presidential palace, and invited his foreign guests to attend the televised coronation.

In a striking departure, Modi also quelled concerns about his rise in the neighbourhood by inviting the heads of government of India's seven South Asian neighbours, as well as that of Mauritius (the Indian Ocean republic whose population is 63 percent Indian), to his swearing-in

The gesture instantly disarmed many across the borders who had been alarmed by his combative rhetoric during the campaign, in which he had promised robust action on the borders, assailed Pakistani sponsorship of terrorism and warned some 30 million Bangladeshi illegal immigrants in India that they should be prepared to pack their backs on the day of his victory. His cordial welcome to, and subsequent bilateral meetings with, the leaders of these and other neighbouring countries reassured them that the Modi government would not feel obliged to live up to the belligerence of the Modi campaign.

So does this all add up to a Modi 2.0, a very different figure in government from the ogre some of us had feared and demonised for years? It is still too early to tell, but the initial signs are encouraging. Prime Minister Modi would hardly be the first opposition leader to temper his views and conduct once in office, but there seems to be something more fundamental involved here. An ambitious man, Modi appears to realize that if he wants to make a success of his government, he will have to lead the nation from the center and not from the extreme right where he had built his base in the BJP.

His overwhelming majority, won on the back of a highly personalized campaign which led many to vote for Modi rather than for the BJP, has also liberated him from the party's and his own past positions. Just as he remade himself from a hate-figure into an avatar of modernity and progress, he is seeking to remake the BJP from a vehicle of Hindu chauvinism to a natural party of governance. This will mean a change in both language and tone, as he has demonstrated from day one.

For an opposition member of Parliament like myself, it would be churlish not to acknowledge Modi 2.0's inclusive outreach and to welcome his more conciliatory statements and actions. The moment he says or does something divisive or sectarian in the Modi 1.0 mould, however, we will resist him robustly. India's people, and its pluralist democracy, deserve no less.


Reprinted from TheWorldPost

Prolific author, Indian member of parliament from Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala (re-elected for a fourth successive term in June 2024), and former Minister of State for External Affairs, Shashi Tharoor has also served as a United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, the Under-Secretary-General for Communications and Public Information, and as a senior advisor to the UN Secretary-General. He is the author, most recently, of Ambedkar: A Life (Aleph Book Company, 2022). His website is

Post a comment

You have 800 characters left for this comment.
The Editors welcome thought-provoking comments, but racist, abusive, intolerant, hate language will not be carried on our pages. All feedback that adds to lively, constructive dialogue will be posted after vetting.
CAPTCHA Image Click to refresh this random text
Jim Bowles (20 June, 2014) – USA
Hardline right wing dominance anywhere is a matter for serious concern, especially if linked to religious extremism of any colour, saffron or green. I think the jury is still out for Mr Modi.
Hirak Nag (17 June, 2014) – India
Most educated and thinking Indians are, firstly happy that the Dynastic rule has been ended, and we now have a dynamic and capable Bharati to guide the country to achieve our just progress by optimum use of our good ingenuity and capability. The undemocratic, dynastic, incapable and crooked rule for the past 66 years has been ended by the intelligent Indian electorate which is in itself an indicator of how we are moving in a true democratic manner, a very encouraging factor. All indians rejoice in anticipation.
vinod gopinath (15 June, 2014) – India
Modi will take a middle path as far as national politics is concerned. In foreign affairs he will try to neutralise the Chinese presence in South Asia. The Chinese [stepped into] Indian territory innumerable times during the the Manmohan regime. They are helping Sri Lanka to rebuild their war-torn Tamil dominated regions. Nepal, Bangladesh etc are also on the Chinese radar. They are trying to smother India by befriending SAARC nations. Pakistan is already a military and business ally. By visiting Bhutan today he is sending a signal to them while using Sushma Swaraj to take care of diplomacy. He is a leader in the mould of A.B Vajpayee though he calls L.K Advani his political Guru. – This comment has been edited
T Matthews (14 June, 2014) – India
This is a nuanced approach by one of India's mercurial politicians who has had a bad run. It shows Tharoor's clear vision and political acumen. If Mr Modi is a worry for minorities and other marginalized elements not covered by the all-embracing Hindu fold then certainly hold him to his words to ensure his deeds match the rhetoric. Why criticize Tharoor?

Long term impact of Gaza attack on Israel

Consequences of Palestinian conflict and finger-pointing in the blame game ... See world opinion

Curse of curation

PR-speak is turning our conversations into outright gibberish... more…